Western Digital WD Red Plus NAS Hard Drive (2TB-12TB) vs Seagate IronWolf NAS Hard Drive (2TB-16TB)

Western Digital WD Red Plus NAS Hard Drive (2TB-12TB)Seagate IronWolf NAS Hard Drive (2TB-16TB)
TypeInternal HDD, NAS-optimized (up to 8 bays)Internal HDD, NAS-optimized
InterfaceSATA 6 Gb/sSATA 6 Gb/s
Form Factor3.5-inch, 26.1 x 101.6 x 147 mm3.5-inch (26.11 x 101.85 x 146.99 mm)
Capacities2, 4, 6, 8, 10, 12 TB2 TB, 4 TB, 6 TB, 8 TB, 10 TB, 12 TB, 16 TB
Recording TechnologyCMR (all models)CMR (all models)
Drive TechnologyAir (helium for WD120EFBX)—
Spindle Speed5400 RPM class (2, 4, 6 TB WD60EFPX), 5640 RPM (8 TB, 6 TB WD60EFZX), 7200 RPM (10 TB, 12 TB)7,200 RPM (16 TB, 12 TB, 10 TB, 8 TB ST8000VN004); 5,400 RPM (8 TB ST8000VN002, 6 TB, 4 TB, 2 TB)
Internal Transfer RateUp to 180 MB/s (2-6 TB) to 260 MB/s (WD100EFGX, WD120EFGX)—
Cache64 MB (2 TB) to 512 MB (WD100EFGX, WD120EFGX), depending on model256 MB
Workload Rate180 TB/year—
MTBF1,000,000 hours1,000,000 hours
Load/Unload Cycles600,000—
Non-Recoverable Read ErrorsLess than 1 in 10^14 bits read—
Operating Temperature0 to 65 C—
Non-Operating Temperature-40 to 70 C—
TechnologiesNASware, dual-plane balance control—
Model NumbersWD20EFPX, WD40EFPX, WD60EFPX, WD60EFZX, WD80EFPX, WD80EFZZ, WD101EFBX, WD100EFGX, WD120EFBX, WD120EFGX—
Warranty3-year limited3-year limited
Max. Sustained Transfer Rate—240 MB/s (16 TB), 210 MB/s (12 TB, 10 TB, 8 TB 7,200 RPM), 202 MB/s (8 TB 5,400 RPM, 6 TB, 4 TB), 180 MB/s (2 TB)
Drive Design—Helium (16 TB, 12 TB); air (10 TB and below)
Drive Bays Supported—1 to 8
Workload Rate Limit—180 TB per year
Rotational Vibration Sensor—Yes
Power-On Hours—8,760 per year (24x7)
Rescue Data Recovery Services—3 years